Spirit Journal al  Spirit Journal subscribe

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 


 

 

 













































































 

 


 












































































 

 


 











































































 

 

 

 










































































 











































































 






















































































































































































 

 

 

 


 


























 

 

 

 




 

 

 
















 

 


 

 

 





















































 

 

 

 


From the Vault

All rights reserved
©2009 F. Paul Pacult
The following reviews first appeared in the September 2009 issue of F. Paul Pacult's Spirit Journal.

WHISKEY - IRELAND

Connemara Peated Single Malt Irish Whiskey Ireland; (Sazerac Company, New Orleans, LA); 40% abv, $40.
Orange/topaz color; very good clarity. Smells remind me of vinyl and candle wax in the initial sniffs after the pour and it's neither sweet nor sour, just, well, a touch plastic-like; additional time in the glass sees the vinyl fade away, leaving behind vegetal notes of tobacco leaf and sea salt. Entry is acutely resiny, peaty-astringent, and woody, almost a touch too much because there's no evidence of grain or fruit or malt to be had until you reach the midpalate stage which does offer an oasis of dried fruit but even less grain/malt. Concludes a bit raw spirit-wise and smoky/peaty.
Spirit Journal 2009 Rating:
Recommended


Connemara Peated Single Malt Irish Whiskey 12 Years Old (Ireland; Sazerac Company, New Orleans, LA); 40% abv, $100.
Pale straw gold color; flawless purity. Oh, yeah, this nose right out of the gate is like kippers/smoked fish and gently sweet pipe smoke; further aeration brings out a sweetish charcoal/barbequed meat fragrance and a citrusy note that I find mesmerizing and keenly inviting. Entry is adequately peaty and iodine-like, but off-dry and nicely crisp; midpalate is quite smoky/tobacco leaf tasting and yet there's an alluring salty dryness that cleans the palate thoroughly. Finishes moderately salty and quite smoky/earthy/peaty.
Spirit Journal 2009 Rating:
Recommended


Connemara Peated Single Malt Irish Whiskey Natural Cask Strength (Ireland; Sazerac Company, New Orleans, LA); 57.9% abv, $60.
Chardonnay-like straw yellow color; quite a lot of debris seen floating about. Floral, garden fresh, and minty scents take me by surprise in the opening rounds of inhaling - wasn't expecting civilization; the bouquet goes all spice cake, dried fruits, and vanilla snap cookies in the second phase after aeration. Entry is wonderously sweet and toffee-like and then it turns spirity and intensely smoked in the midpalate stage that also features toasted marshmallow and roasted nuts. Concludes more bittersweet than sweet as the veil of smoke thickens.
Spirit Journal 2009 Rating:
Highly Recommended


Tyrconnell Single Malt Madeira Cask Irish Whiskey 10 Year Old (Ireland; Sazerac Company, New Orleans, LA); 46% abv, $90.
Very pretty orange-ish amber hue; ideal clarity. Comes off prickly in the first whiffs after the pour as the spirit stakes its claim early and with gusto; following six minutes in the glass, the aroma turns waxy (like butcher's wax paper) and paraffin-like; there's something hollow in this bouquet. Entry is sappy/resiny at first, then it turns intensely creamy/nutty; midpalate is semisweet, bean/kernel-like (coffee bean), and surprisingly, aggressively bitter/astringent. Ends up like dark caramel or high-cocoa-content dark chocolate in its bitterness.
Spirit Journal 2009 Rating:
Recommended


Tyrconnell Single Malt Port Cask Irish Whiskey 10 Year Old (Ireland; Sazerac Company, New Orleans, LA); 46% abv, $90.
Topaz/burnished gold color; totally sediment free. Spirity notes come rushing out of the glass after the pour as well as lush, ripe, fruity aromas that are kept somewhat hidden by the alcohol thrust; seven minutes into the aeration process, the spirit settles down, leaving the path open for juicy scents of plums and red grapes. Entry is sweet, ripe, and cocoa butter-like; midpalate features long, bittersweet tastes of orange rind/zest, figs, dates, and cocoa. Finishes semisweet, sappy/resiny, and a bit brittle.
Spirit Journal 2009 Rating:
Recommended


Tyrconnell Single Malt Sherry Cask Irish Whiskey 10 Year Old (Ireland; Sazerac Company, New Orleans, LA); 46% abv, $90.
Funny to me that the Sherry Cask is the darkest of the three fortified wine cask expressions; would have expected the Port or Madeira to be darker. Deep amber/saffron/bronze color; impeccable purity. Toasty fragrances of baked bread, toasted nuts, and baked pears make for interesting first stage sniffing; the bake-a-thon continues in the second phase as enticingly roasted/sautéed aromas abound; the meatiest, most compelling bouquet of the three expressions. Entry is fruity/grapy/jammy; midpalate highlights the fruit but more in a baked/pastry shop manner, as the fruit almost seems coated in chocolate or caramel. Concludes sweet and smoky (pipe tobacco).
Spirit Journal 2009 Rating:
Recommended


The Wild Geese Irish Soldiers & Heroes Classic Blend Blended Irish Whiskey (Ireland; MHW, Ltd., Manhasset, NY); 40% abv, $39.
Has a chardonnay yellow/gold appearance; excellent clarity. Smells remind me of dry breakfast cereal that is slightly sweetened; second passes after further aeration bring out a mild honey note that works well with the cereal quality plus there's a dash of spice. Entry is crisp, moderately sweet in a honeyed manner, and spiced; midpalate stage doesn't necessarily expand much on what was discerned at entry, but that's not to say that I'm disappointed, because I'm not. Sweetness in the aftertaste turns sappy and slightly maple-like. Good overall.
Spirit Journal 2009 Rating:
Recommended


The Wild Geese Irish Soldiers & Heroes Rare Blended Irish Whiskey (Ireland; MHW, Ltd., Manhasset, NY); 43% abv, $49.
Deepest 18-carat gold color of the product line; impeccable purity. This opening aroma offers woody notes that are clean, horizontal, and lightly spiced (tarragon); admittedly not the deepest Irish whiskey bouquet in the world, this bantamweight aroma is nonetheless mildly pleasing, nutty, and a touch zestier after six minutes of aeration. Entry is prickly and moderately sweet in a toffee-like manner; midpalate shows a nice leathery texture and a honeyed sweetness that's both charming and substantial. Ends on a buttery note that puts it over the top for a fourth rating star.
Spirit Journal 2009 Rating:
Highly Recommended


The Wild Geese Irish Soldiers & Heroes Limited Edition Fourth Centennial Blended Irish Whiskey (Ireland; MHW, Ltd., Manhasset, NY); 43% abv, $69.
White wine yellow color; minor debris spotted. Hello? Where is the opening aroma on this whiskey because, fellow humans, I can't locate it and my olfactory sense is second only to a bloodhound's; thinking that some swirling and additional time in the glass would help, I am proven wrong; vapid, perhaps mildly grainy, but basically AWOL. Entry is a touch too hot, raw, and biting; midpalate is surprisingly flat, showing meager tastes of pepper, resin, oil, pine. Ends fairly well on a grainy note, but where was that grainy note when this whiskey really needed it in the aroma, entry, and midpalate? Pass on it. With the Classic and Rare available, why even do this one? Thankfully it's a limited edition.
Spirit Journal 2009 Rating:
Not Recommended


The Wild Geese Irish Soldiers & Heroes Single Malt Irish Whiskey (Ireland; MHW, Ltd., Manhasset, NY); 43% abv, $89.
Yellow gold appearance; flawless purity. Offers some fairly attractive, if meek aromas of cookie batter, bread dough, and light toffee in the initial whiffs after the pour; secondary inhalations dig up more in the way of malt, biscuits, light baking spice, and oak; not a landmark aroma but okay. Entry is pleasingly buttery/oily in the first impression then turns metallic/minerally/lead pencil-like at midpalate, which doesn't score big with me. This whiskey loses its way at the final stage of the entry where its flavor turns coin-like and metallic. Drinkable, but that's the best I can say about it.
Spirit Journal 2009 Rating:
Not Recommended

SINGLE MALT WHISKY - FRANCE

Armorik French Single Malt Whisky (France; Preiss Imports, Ramona, CA); 46% abv, $59.
Soft-focus straw yellow color; good purity. Smells properly grainy and dry breakfast cereal-like, even peppery in the initial aromatic go-rounds; the peppery spiciness grows in concentration, making the bouquet almost caraway seed-like and very roasted/toasty; I like it a lot. Entry features the acute spiciness of the latter stages of the nose but in taste form; midpalate is off-dry, crisp, astringent, and more nutty than spicy as a keen nut paste/nut butter aspect takes charge and leads into the semisweet, maple-like aftertaste. In three words, cracker barrel 'licious!
Spirit Journal 2009 Rating:
Highly Recommended



DISTILLERY ISSUE SINGLE MALT WHISKY - SCOTLAND

Arran Malt Pomerol Bordeaux Wine Casks Isle of Arran Single Malt Whisky (Scotland; A Hardy USA, Rosemont, IL); 50% abv, $80.
Peach-like rose/gold color; very good clarity. Opening nosings encounter piquant, peppery scents that are one part elevated spirit, one part spiciness, and one part ripe grapes; further aeration settles down the spiritiness while bumping up the acute peppery and ripe fruit aspects that go off the charts in inhaling pleasure. Entry is intensely grapy but also cereally, quite like breakfast cereal mixed with raisins; midpalate is long, medium oily, yet astringent, spirity, and nearly austere in its razor-like acidity. One of the best Arrans, period. Holy-moly this is luscious and is a wine lover's dream malt.
Spirit Journal 2009 Rating:
Highest Recommendation


Arran Malt St. Emilion Grand Cru Classé Wine Casks Isle of Arran Single Malt Whisky (Scotland; A Hardy USA, Rosemont, IL); 50% abv, $80.
Burnished copper/amontillado sherry color; superb purity. First sniffs pick up defined scents of ripe red grapes, grape jam, and cereal mixed with fruit, especially raisins and nectarines; after another eight minutes of air contact, the aromatic profile definitely leans on the side of dried fruit, trail mix, and candied nuts. Entry is full-weighted, incredibly oily and sleek, fruity, and buttery; midpalate ably carries all these impressions to the next stage with the spirit not making a real dent until the finish which is smooth, ripe, off-dry to semisweet, intensely oaky/sappy, and assertive. A powerhouse malt.
Spirit Journal 2009 Rating:
Highly Recommended


Auchentoshan Classic Lowlands Single Malt Scotch Whisky (Scotland; Skyy Spirits LLC, San Francisco, CA); 40% abv, $30.
Jonquil/gamboges/dusty yellow gold color; flawless clarity. Smells nicely of spice cake/winter holiday pastries (plenty of cinnamon and vanilla) in the initial inhalations; aeration turns the aroma fruitier and properly grainy/mashy/malty. Entry offers medium-sweet, light textured tastes of vanilla bean, spice cake, and oak; midpalate is deeper than the entry, offering more in the way of substantive taste impact that is delicately sweet, grainy, and engagingly spicy in keeping with the aroma. Concludes medium-long, bakery shop sweet and doughy, and altogether simple and straightforward.
Spirit Journal 2009 Rating:
Recommended


Auchentoshan 12 Year Old Lowlands Single Malt Scotch Whisky (Scotland; Skyy Spirits LLC, San Francisco, CA); 43% abv, $46.
Bronze/amber hue; unblemished purity. First aromas include cement, woodsy vegetation, and hemp/rope; swirling and additional time in the glass don't coax more interesting aromas to emerge, leaving behind a bland wet linen quality that's lacking in charm. Entry displays a low-degree of sap-like maple sweetness and a touch of oak vanillin; midpalate is toasty, roasted, semisweet, and even a touch oily. Finishes delicate, elegant, mildly toasty, and grainy. Entry, midpalate, and finish made up for aromatic deficiencies.
Spirit Journal 2009 Rating:
Recommended


Auchentoshan Three Wood Lowlands Single Malt Scotch Whisky (Scotland; Skyy Spirits LLC, San Francisco, CA); 43% abv, $57.
Last reviewed in 1999 and rated Five Stars. By far, the most eye-catching Auchentoshan of all; ochre/saffron/henna color; impeccable clarity. Lots going on in the initial sniffs, including scents of toasted grain, yeast, bread dough, and light toffee; later whiffs encounter semisweet aromas of Sherry, honey, caramelized onion, tropical fruits, and flax. Entry is peppery, oily, rich, and a little metallic/coin-like; midpalate shakes off the trace of metal coin and focuses promptly on Sherry/honey, ripe red fruit like plums, chocolate cake frosting, and honey, honey, and even more honey. Aftertaste is buttery, bacon fat-like, bacon rind-like, and charred meat-like.
Spirit Journal 2009 Rating:
Highly Recommended


Auchentoshan 21 Year Old Lowlands Single Malt Scotch Whisky (Scotland; Skyy Spirits LLC, San Francisco, CA); 40% abv, $140.
Last reviewed in 1994 and rated Four Stars. Topaz/amber color; ideal purity. Scents of flax/hemp and wax open the aromatic proceedings in a workmanlike manner; additional air exposure brings out meager aromas of wet fabric, shale, and papaya. Entry features candied fruit and nuts in abundance; midpalate is grainy sweet, almost like sweetened breakfast cereal, fruity, and floral. Ends on a high note of sweet barley malt, oak, and cooking spice (white peppercorn).
Spirit Journal 2009 Rating:
Highly Recommended


The Balvenie Signature 12 Years Old 2009 Limited Release Batch No. 002 Speyside Single Malt Scotch Whisky (Scotland; William Grant & Sons, New York, NY); 43% abv, $65.
Bright bronze/amber color; impeccable clarity. Smells of barley malt, light peat, and chocolate covered orange peel in the initial whiffs; the depth of the barley fragrance knows no limits and that brewery house/distillery quality is fetching in its own right; love this malty, no nonsense bouquet. Entry is semisweet, with succulent tastes of brown sugar, nougat, and almonds coated in chocolate; the bakery/sweet shop feast continues in the midpalate stage as the taste profile turns slightly away from the sweetness and more towards the oiliness/resininess of the oak influence, thereby making for a highly complex and intricate taste experience. What Speyside is all about, mon amis.
Spirit Journal 2009 Rating:
Highly Recommended


The Balvenie PortWood 21 Years Old Speyside Single Malt Scotch Whisky (Scotland; William Grant & Sons, New York, NY); 43% abv, $180.
Last evaluated in 1997 when I gave it three rating stars. Highly attractive copper/burnished orange color; nearly flawless purity. Shows the Balvenie aromatic thumbprint of barley/light peat but goes further with lovely traces of oak resin, salted butter, and salted almond; further aeration stimulates supplemental notes of wax, black raisins, and parchment. Entry is sleek, nuanced in its portiness, and gently not overtly sweet; midpalate is fuller than the entry and more generous in flavor, offering oak-driven vanillin and traces of ruby port, lead pencil, bark, and dried nectarine. Concludes fruity, dry, and medium-rich. I agree with my initial evaluation.
Spirit Journal 2009 Rating:
Recommended


The Balvenie Vintage Cask 1976 Speyside Single Malt Scotch Whisky (Scotland; William Grant & Sons, New York, NY); 53% abv, $850.
Gamboge/straw color; unblemished clarity. Offers an atypical (for Balvenie) lack of barley/light smoke-peat in the first go-round, but fills those holes with tree fruits, especially ripe pear, nectarine, and red apple; the nose turns more flax-like, fibery, and lean after the aeration period of eight minutes. Entry is tightly-wound, waxy, lean, and off-dry; midpalate focuses more on the oak barrel resins as well as the vanillin aspect, making for very focused enjoyment. Ends on an oily, flex-like, resiny, coconut note that is neither dry nor sweet, but somewhere in between. A thought provoking malt.
Spirit Journal 2009 Rating:
Highly Recommended


Bruichladdich Eighteen Islay Single Malt Scotch Whisky (Scotland; Winebow, Montvale, NJ); 46% abv, $125.
Very pretty autumn gold/harvest grain amber color; excellent purity. Initial whiffs pick up delicate aromas of baked pear, honeywheat bread toast, and nectarine; aeration adds minor scent traces of lanolin, sawdust, and malted barley. Entry is long, nicely textured, moderately sweet in a caramel manner and balanced; midpalate is all about the barley as the taste profile turns slightly drier and biscuity. Concludes sappy, resiny, salty, and semisweet.
Spirit Journal 2009 Rating:
Highly Recommended


Bruichladdich Golder Still Islay Single Malt Scotch Whisky (Scotland; Winebow, Montvale, NJ); 51% abv, $275.
Medium amber/harvest gold appearance; flawless purity. The spiritiness of the opening aroma might be a bit much for the uninitiated but I like this kind of fruity, eye-popping how-do-you-do; secondary sniffs dig up roasted chestnut, pine, sawn wood, and barley malt. Entry is firm, balanced between acidity, abv, and oak; midpalate displays serious character and depth as the flavor profile includes brown butter, sea salt, old oak, cedar wood, and brown sugar aspects. Finishes beautifully piquant and prickly.
Spirit Journal 2009 Rating:
Highly Recommended


Bruichladdich 16 Year Old Bourbon Cask Islay Single Malt Scotch Whisky (Scotland; Winebow, Montvale, NJ); 46% abv, $99.
Pale 14-carat gold/straw color; superb clarity. Wow, a stunningly lush and buttery aromatic opening that's part ripe tropical fruit (banana, kiwi), part bubble gum, and part raspberry preserves - as I said, wow; the ripe berry fruit leaps forward after further air contact, but the overall aromatic thrust settles down into a calm, composed winner. Entry is grainy sweet and incredibly oily/buttery/creamy to the touch; midpalate turns off the berry spigot and moves in the direction of charred meat, oak resin, fudge, and dark caramel. Oh, that first sniff!
Spirit Journal 2009 Rating:
Highly Recommended


Bruichladdich 16 Year Old Cuvee A Chateau Lafite barrels Islay Single Malt Scotch Whisky (Scotland; Winebow, Montvale, NJ); 46% abv, $99.
Attractive rosy orange color; perfect clarity. Dry to the nose in the initial sniffs, but with a distant trace of grape jam and dried orange/tangerine; the nose gets more spirity after further air contact, but it also picks up in the dried fruit aspect; shows some minor spice as well. Entry is clean, lean, crisp, and intensely oaky; midpalate pushes past the oakiness and introduces light brine and plenty of acidity. I like the refreshment factor of this malt, though it may be too brittle for malt drinkers who appreciate plumpness and a bit of sweetness.
Spirit Journal 2009 Rating:
Recommended


Bruichladdich 16 Year Old Cuvee B Chateau Latour barrels Islay Single Malt Scotch Whisky (Scotland; Winebow, Montvale, NJ); 46% abv, $99.
Rose/gold/copper/orange color; unblemished purity. First inhalations after the pour detect savory fragrances of ash, shale, herbs, and old oak; nose goes mute after seven minutes of aeration. Entry is sublimely sweet and ripe and medium thick on the tongue; midpalate offers integrated flavors of honey, nougat, light toffee, and chocolate covered cherry. Finishes semisweet, crisp, yet with some fat, and a last blast of saltiness. More developed as a package than the severe and ascetic Cuvee A.
Spirit Journal 2009 Rating:
Highly Recommended


Bruichladdich 2001 Resurrection Dram Islay Single Malt Scotch Whisky (Scotland; Winebow, Montvale, NJ); 46% abv, $79.
Jonquil color; excellent clarity. Now we're talking classic Islay brininess here in this pungent, sea breeze aroma that also has hints of baked banana and saltwater taffy; the aroma gets smokier/peatier after further aeration. Entry is surprisingly sweet and sap-like; midpalate is smoky, ashy, woody, oily, briny, and flat-out delicious. Concludes firm, sweet, woody/resiny, and elegant. Like it a lot.
Spirit Journal 2009 Rating:
Recommended


Edradour 10 Year Old Central Highlands Single Malt Scotch Whisky (Scotland; Total Beverage Solution, Mt. Pleasant, SC); 43% abv, $65.
Pretty old gold/amontillado Sherry color; superb purity. First nosings pick up delightfully sweet notes of almond paste, nougat, and barley malt; delicate spice and confectioner elements emerge after additional aeration time; this is an ethereal bouquet of subtle charms. Entry is lithe, gently spiced and medium-sweet; midpalate is nearly buttery, gingerbread-like, spice cake-like, and elegant. Ends in a flurry of spice notes. Evaluated originally in 1993 at two stars, I'm more than happy to upgrade that to a solid three stars/borderline four.
Spirit Journal 2009 Rating:
Recommended


Glenrothes 1991 Speyside Single Malt Scotch Whisky (Scotland; Skyy Spirits, San Francisco, CA); 43% abv, $75.
Maize/old gold color; unblemished clarity. Reminds me of sautéed almonds or walnuts in the first nosing blast; following another seven minutes of air contact, the nuttiness becomes more of a dried fruit bouquet, as well as caramel, dark toffee and butterscotch leaning; a complex and integrated aroma. Entry is round, oily, succulent, and like white raisins; midpalate is rich, deeply caramel-like and shows signs of bacon fat and marzipan in the final stage. Ends on a lush, viscous note that is once again nutty and wonderfully bittersweet. Another sumptuous, top grade winner from this esteemed Speyside distiller.
Spirit Journal 2009 Rating:
Highest Recommendation


Glenrothes 1975 Speyside Single Malt Scotch Whisky (Scotland; Skyy Spirits, San Francisco, CA); 43% abv, $525.
Bronze/burnished orange hue; perfect purity. I smell light smoke/peat in the opening round of sniffing; seven minutes of further exposure to air brings out dry cereal, barley, oats, and oakiness. Entry is medium-sweet, sap-like, and resiny; midpalate offers greater depth and richer tastes of barley, dried fruit (cherry), honey, and vanilla. Concludes long, beany/spicy, and integrated on all fronts.
Spirit Journal 2009 Rating:
Highly Recommended


Isle of Jura 10 Year Old Isle of Jura Single Malt Whisky (Scotland; Sazerac Company, New Orleans, LA); 43% abv, $38.
Topaz/harvest gold color; perfect purity. Softly sweet and very biscuity/cookie batter-like in the first inhalations after the pour; the delicate aromatics don't really deepen with aeration, they maintain the status quo. Entry is gently sweet and intensely nutty; midpalate features tangy, low-impact saltiness and a butter cream texture and taste that make it easily recommendable, even if it's not what I'd consider complex. Ends up amiably sweet and toasted. A good beginner's dram.
Spirit Journal 2009 Rating:
Recommended


Macallan 18 Year Old Sherry Oak Speyside Single Malt Scotch Whisky (Scotland; Remy Cointreau USA, New York, NY); 43% abv, $150.
Last formally reviewed in 1992 (Five Stars). One of the greatest single malt appearances of all time; brilliant copper/orange color; impeccable purity. The first sniffs detect deep notes of toasted chestnut, brown butter, salted butter, and marzipan; secondary passes after an additional eight minutes of air contact bring out the oloroso Sherry in all its dried fruit/raisin/fig glory, but also oak, treacle, chocolate fudge, and chocolate covered cherries. Entry is fathomlessly deep, rich without being unctuous, sweet without being cloying, and as elegant as any other 18 year old malt whisky around. An enduring classic and a benchmark for robust Speysides.
Spirit Journal 2009 Rating:
Highest Recommendation


Port Ellen 29 Year Old 8th Release/Cask Strength Islay Single Malt Whisky (Scotland; Diageo N.A., Norwalk, CT); 55.3% abv, $400.
Straw yellow/gamboges color; ideal clarity. Sea salt, green Manzanilla olive, brine, band-aid plaster, and other saline aromatic delights are present and accounted for in the opening inhalations; further aeration time allows for the saline aspects to gradually build to a crescendo. Entry is surprisingly sweet and toasted/smoky; midpalate is even sweeter than the entry and saltier than the aroma and I appreciate the assertiveness of the complex, intricate, remarkably honeyed taste. One of the better ones in this annual series.
Spirit Journal 2009 Rating:
Highest Recommendation


Springbank 11 Year Old Madeira Wood Campbeltown Single Malt Scotch Whisky Cask Strength (Scotland; Preiss Imports, Ramona, CA); 55.1% abv, $99.
Amber color; superb purity. The elevated abv (cask strength) offers prickly, keenly peppery opening scents that piggyback atop the cleany, flax- and kernel-like aromatic foundation; the spirit travels up the nasal cavity tweaking all the way and leaving behind intensely grainy/breakfast cereal scents that rock. Entry is surprisingly tame next to the rambunctious nature of the bouquet as fruity tastes of plums and dates abound; midpalate is vibrant with spirit and wine-like tastes that go beyond the grain/malt/kernel base to semisweet heights. Finishes long, chewy, buttery, and ideally sweet yet crisp.
Spirit Journal 2009 Rating:
Highest Recommendation


Springbank 18 Year Old Campbeltown Single Malt Scotch Whisky (Scotland; Preiss Imports, Ramona, CA); 46% abv, $189.
Pretty, bright maize/marigold color; perfect clarity. Ooooh, this lovely, biscuity nose begins toasty, gently sweet, malty, fruity, and even a touch nutty; following another seven minutes of air contact, the aroma settles into grain-o-rama mode that includes hints of oak and cedar/pine. Entry is nothing short of delicious as the taste profile goes caramel sweet, tangy/salty, and baked; midpalate soars with limitless flavors of cocoa, hot fudge, nougat, hot buttered rum, vanilla extract, and deep oakiness. Concludes warm as embers in the throat, semisweet, and demarara sugar-like. To use the most technical term I can think of: wowee-wow-wow-wow.
Spirit Journal 2009 Rating:
Highest Recommendation

INDEPENDENT MERCHANT SINGLE MALT & SINGLE GRAIN WHISKY - SCOTLAND

Duncan Taylor NC2 Range Ben Nevis 1996 Western Highlands Single Malt Scotch Whisky (Scotland; Preiss Imports, Ramona, CA); 46% abv, $83.
Very pale yellow appearance; unblemished clarity. Smells sweet, salty, and grainy right out of the gate, even a touch herbal/fresh garden-like; the herbal aspect gives way to a yellow fruit quality that reminds me of baked pears after another seven minutes of air contact; very pleasant nosing. Entry is slightly salty, mildly peated, and nearly austere in its high acidity and medium-bodied texture; midpalate highlights the yellow fruit with traces of leather and margarine. Ends biscuity and just a shade sweet. Nice job here.
Spirit Journal 2009 Rating:
Recommended


Duncan Taylor Cameronbridge 1979 Cask #3584 Single Grain Scotch Whisky (Scotland; Preiss Imports, Ramona, CA); 49.5% abv, $180.
Bright amber/marigold color; superb clarity. Opening whiffs detect prickly, piquant scents that are spirity and gently fruity; after further aeration, the bouquet turns doughy and bread-like, with sophisticated aromas of yeast, early morning bakery, and breakfast cereal. Entry is rich, lip-smacking honeyed, and citrusy; midpalate soars with dried fruit tastes, including prunes, apricots, banana, baked marshmallow and cranberry. Finishes well and robust. Whoever claims that grain whiskies can't hold their own on their own should sample this dandy whisky.
Spirit Journal 2009 Rating:
Highly Recommended


Duncan Taylor Cameronbridge 1978 Cask #12 Single Grain Scotch Whisky (Scotland; Preiss Imports, Ramona, CA); 57.4% abv, $188.
Old gold color; impeccable purity. A big rush of warm spiritiness leaps from the sampling glass in the initial inhalations, but there's also a keen spiciness (cinnamon) that lies beneath the abv thrust; following seven more minutes of air contact, the spirit blows off leaving behind lovely scents of new leather, flax, and banana. Entry reveals a concentrated cereal quality that's intense and semisweet; midpalate takes the cereal aspect further, driven totally by the elevated spirit. Concludes spirity, nearly hot, and extremely grainy/flax-like.
Spirit Journal 2009 Rating:
Recommended


Duncan Taylor Caol Ila 1982 Cask #2735 Islay Single Malt Scotch Whisky (Scotland; Preiss Imports, Ramona, CA); 53.6% abv, $197.
Medium amber/14-carat gold color; completely sediment-free. I note salty aromas of seaweed/kelp upfront but they are buttressed by softer malty scents that border on being saltwater taffy-like; later whiffs detect a fading of the saltiness/sea breeze and an ascendancy of biscuits/cookies/snack cracker scent. Entry features brine, dried herbs (sage especially), and cigarette tobacco; midpalate is tightly wound, edgy, crisp, acidic, and properly smoky for the region. I wasn't bowled over by this Caol Ila expression, but it's very good and amiable.
Spirit Journal 2009 Rating:
Recommended


Duncan Taylor Carsebridge 1978 Cask #33041 Single Grain Scotch Whisky (Scotland; Preiss Imports, Ramona, CA); 54.8% abv, $173.
Attractive burnished orange/maize color; excellent purity. Offers plump, doughy, bakery fragrances in the opening sniffs that could almost be called "fruity" though perhaps ripe and round are better terms; additional air contact brings out a spicy aspect that's complementary to the bakery/dough/biscuity elements; hardly a complex bouquet, but nice nonetheless. Entry displays a round, chewy viscosity that is highlighted by semisweet flavors of toasted marshmallow and butterscotch; the sweetness continues into the midpalate as the taste profile turns warmer as the abv aspect picks up steam. Is this a benchmark grain whisky? No. Is it recommendable? By all means, yes.
Spirit Journal 2009 Rating:
Recommended


Duncan Taylor Dalmore 1990 Cask #D311 Northern Highlands Single Malt Scotch Whisky (Scotland; Preiss Imports, Ramona, CA); 56.7% abv, $128.
Medium amber/straw/18-carat gold color; some sediment seen; not pristine. Smells of steamed brown rice, new leather, and dried banana in the opening round of sniffing; further aeration time brings out pine nut and light caramel elements that are mild but pleasing. Entry is firmly structured, engagingly warm, nutty, and gently sweet; midpalate is long, buttery/oily, a trace salty/peaty, and round and full. Finishes on a semisweet note that's very piny/cedary/resiny.
Spirit Journal 2009 Rating:
Highly Recommended


Duncan Taylor North British Cask #38473 Single Grain Scotch Whisky (Scotland; Preiss Imports, Ramona, CA); 55.4% abv, $176.
Pale amber/sauternes yellow color; flawless clarity. Light toffee and caramel highlight the initial whiffs in this simple and straightforward bouquet; the candy quality blows off leaving in its wake a tight-fisted, austere grain aspect that's shallow. Entry is very caramel-like and dried fruit-like, almost toasty and honeyed in its sweetness; midpalate features ample fudge, cocoa, and nougat notes that don't overshadow the vibrant spirit. Ends clean, full-bodied, vigorous. Again, not a landmark achievement in grain whisky as few are, but very good indeed.
Spirit Journal 2009 Rating:
Recommended


Duncan Taylor Royal Lochnagar 1990 Cask #355 Eastern Highlands Single Malt Scotch Whisky (Scotland; Preiss Imports, Ramona, CA); 54.2% abv, $174.
Yellow gold/jonquil appearance; excellent purity. Initial whiffs encounter low-key scents of wax, lanolin, and toffee; added time in glass of seven minutes doesn't accomplish much in the way of aromatic expansion. Entry is taut, lean, austere yet wonderfully spicy and tangy; midpalate features more assertive, broader tastes including nougat, marzipan, dark chocolate/cocoa, honey, and, if one digs extra deep, oloroso Sherry. Ends on a candy bar note that's more semisweet than sweet and nutty. Wow, the entry, midpalate, and aftertaste are dynamite.
Spirit Journal 2009 Rating:
Highly Recommended


Duncan Taylor Strathclyde 1980 Cask #1497 Single Grain Scotch Whisky (Scotland; Preiss Imports, Ramona, CA); 56.7% abv, $214.
Pretty medium amber/18-carat gold color; ideal clarity. This opening nose emits attractive scents of sugar cookie/biscuit, almond paste, and cocoa; the aroma flattens out slightly after another seven minutes of air exposure, but the appealing rudimentary aspects are still alive and accounted for. Entry is acutely sweet and brown sugar-like, almost rum-like; midpalate is like confectioner's sugar, sweetened cake frosting, and vanilla-flavored biscuits. Finishes sappy, maple-like, and intensely sweet and resiny.
Spirit Journal 2009 Rating:
Recommended


Wemyss Vintage Malts The Peat Chimney Blended Malt Scotch Whisky (Scotland; PA Bock Wines & Spirits, San Francisco, CA/Specialty Imports, Peoria, IL); 40% abv, $42.
Bright jonquil/saffron color; unblemished clarity. Semisweet fragrances of pipe tobacco, bonfire smoke, kippers, and ash highlight the first whiffs; following eight minutes of stand-alone aeration, the sweetness blows off, leaving behind nicely ashy notes of smoldering fire, cigarette ash, wood smoke, and kippers/smoked fish. Entry is surprisingly flat and just a touch spicy, but a bit blah considering the smokiness; midpalate is a touch livelier as the sweetness makes a return to bolster and complement the heavy smokiness. Concludes nicely in a pipe tobacco manner.
Spirit Journal 2009 Rating:
Recommended

BLENDED WHISKY - SCOTLAND

Black Bull 30 Year Old Blended Scotch Whisky (Scotland; Preiss Imports, Ramona, CA); 50% abv, $199.
Half malt whisky and half grain whisky; non-chill filtered; matured in sherry casks. Auburn/tarnished copper color; excellent purity. First inhalations detect aromas of dark honey, molasses, and demerara sugar; the second passes following further aeration encounter bittersweet, fudge-like aromas that are dark, confectionery-like, and transfixing; a Big League Sherry butt bouquet. Entry is very sweet in a high cocoa content dark chocolate way rather than a sugary manner; midpalate is deep, bittersweet, complex, oily/resiny, and not the least bit fat or flabby. Finishes intense, concentrated, and bittersweet. Not for everyone, but an intriguing blend with lots going for it.
Spirit Journal 2009 Rating:
Highly Recommended


Buchanan's Deluxe 12 Year Old Blended Scotch Whisky (Scotland; Diageo N.A., Norwalk, CT); 40% abv, $38.
Last reviewed in 1992 and rated Three Stars. Bright amber/old gold color; good clarity. Nose after opening pour is faintly grainy and gently spirity; aromatic profile opens up a smidgen following aeration as it gives off delicate scents of salted peanut, oak plank, and cooking oil. Entry is oaky/resiny/maple-like and medium-sweet; midpalate is chewy, textured, almost viscous, and honey sweet. Finishes long, toffee sweet, and fudge-like.
Spirit Journal 2009 Rating:
Recommended


Buchanan's Special Reserve 18 Year Old Blended Scotch Whisky (Scotland; Diageo N.A., Norwalk, CT); 43% abv, $80.
Last reviewed in 1997 and given Four Stars. Gorgeous, brilliant, burnished orange/bronze color; impeccable purity. Very spirity, nearly prickly in the first inhalations, but also fruity and nutty; the fruit/nut combination races to the forefront with aeration, providing an animated and pleasing bouquet stage. Entry is resiny and unabashedly sap-like and deliciously caramelly; midpalate highlights the caramel aspect to the hilt, but also includes assertive flavors of praline, buttered pecan, and butter cookies. Ends up bakery shop sweet and with a newly added twist of spice that rounds the finish off well. Generous and concentrated.
Spirit Journal 2009 Rating:
Highly Recommended


Buchanan's Red Seal Blended Scotch Whisky (Scotland; Diageo N.A., Norwalk, CT); 40% abv, $144.
Pretty topaz/harvest gold/marigold color; excellent clarity. Shows a bakery shop sweetness and oakiness in the initial whiffs that tweak my interest to smell more; the sweetness fades slightly after more time in the glass, leaving room for the wood and also an emerging graininess/muesli quality that's nice and toasted. Entry is malty/mashy/grainy sweet and viscous; midpalate is long and luxurious in maple and sweetened cereal tastes that are admittedly near over-the-top, but nonetheless enjoyable and honest. Not much contemplation time is required to enjoy.
Spirit Journal 2009 Rating:
Highly Recommended


Dewar's Founder's Reserve 18 Year Old Blended Scotch Whisky (Scotland; John Dewar & Sons, Miami, FL); 40% abv, $80.
Very bright saffron/amber color; impeccable purity. Delicate scents of baking spices and sweet grains make themselves apparent in the opening round of inhaling; further air contact brings out a slight candied/sugar glaze aspect that's pleasant, though not deep. Entry offers rich, dark toffee, and toasted marshmallow flavors in abundance; midpalate is likewise caramel sweet and toasty, with a medium oily texture and underpinning tastes of marzipan and brown sugar. Aftertaste is long, gently sweet, and seriously grainy.
Spirit Journal 2009 Rating:
Highly Recommended


Pinch The Dimple 15 Year Old Blended Scotch Whisky (Scotland; Diageo N.A., Norwalk, CT); 43% abv, $32.
Last formally evaluated in 1992 and rated Four Stars. Medium amber/topaz hue; sparse sediment seen, though inconsequential to the appearance. I immediately pick up lots of yellow fruits in the initial whiffs, everything from pear to nectarine to banana; the fruitiness continues nicely in the second stage sniffs as the fruit turns a bit more ripe and sweet. Entry is caramel sweet and full of baking spices, especially vanilla and nutmeg; midpalate is medium full, beautifully oily in texture, sap-like and resiny, and like honey-coated cereal. Finish is buttery, creamy, a touch roasted, and very satiny. A blended Scotch that is vastly underappreciated in the U.S. Excellent, in particular, in the entry, midpalate and finish phases.
Spirit Journal 2009 Rating:
Highly Recommended


Royale Salute 21 Year Old (Chivas Brothers) Blended Scotch Whisky (Scotland; Pernod Ricard USA, New York, NY); 40% abv, $200.
Last reviewed in 1995 and rated Five Stars. Attractive orange/bronze color; flawless purity. Lightly smells of toasted grain and baked pears in the initial inhalations after the pour; additional time in the glass allows for slightly deeper scents in the tropical fruit forms of banana and pineapple; I am concerned that the bouquet seems more timid than when I last evaluated it in 1995. Entry is tidy, neat, and trim while still offering tastes of light toffee, sweet malt, and light oak; midpalate is the high point since it reeks of elegance in a dried fruit and cereal manner. Ends gracefully, composed, tight, and yet somewhat lackluster. With reluctance, I'm downgrading Royal Salute by one rating star. Go for Chivas 18.
Spirit Journal 2009 Rating:
Highly Recommended

BLENDED WHISKY - CANADA

Crown Royal Cask No. 16 Blended Canadian Whisky (Canada; Diageo N.A., Norwalk, CT); 40% abv, $99.
Defines "bronze" in a whisky appearance; flawlessly clean and clear. Smells of leather, cereal grain, breakfast cereal, and dates in the first sniffs; bouquet expands with seven minutes of aeration to include raisins, nuts, and figs. Entry is lushly delicious and silky textured, with big flavors of grape preserves and black plums; midpalate is semisweet and concentrated on dried fruits, especially black raisins and prunes, but there's also a fine wood aspect that's just slightly resiny but more sweet and vanilla-like. Finishes with elegance, substance, and tons and tons of dried fruits.
Spirit Journal 2009 Rating:
Highest Recommendation

WHISKEY - USA

Elijah Craig 12 Year Old Kentucky Straight Bourbon Whiskey (USA; Heaven Hill Distilleries, Bardstown, KY); 47% abv, $18.

Owns a reddish brown henna/auburn color that's very pretty; unblemished clarity. Smells out of the gate like dried fruits (prunes, black raisins) and honey; seven more minutes of aeration stimulate deeper, more confectioner's shop-like fudge, dark caramel, nougat, and dried apricot. The entry is succulent, semisweet, toffee-like, and luscious; midpalate is resiny/sawdust-like, oily/buttery, caramel-like and just plain old dried red fruit delicious. Finishes as savory and integrated as it begins. An ideal American whiskey of the highest order.
Spirit Journal 2009 Rating:
Highest Recommendation


Fighting Cock 6 Year Old Kentucky Straight Bourbon Whiskey (USA; Heaven Hill Distilleries, Bardstown, KY); 51.5% abv, $17.
One of the darkest and, I think, prettiest bourbons in the marketplace; deep henna/ochre/chestnut color; superb clarity. Smells of old leather/men's club and pipe tobacco in the first whiffs; eight minutes of added aeration brings out deep bakery shop notes of chocolate covered truffles, almond paste, and paraffin. Entry is sweet yet not cloying and fruity in a dried fruit or better baked fruit (banana, apricot, pear) manner; midpalate is spirity and warming and caramel sweet. I sampled this in the late 1990s and I like it more now. Seems deeper and more substantial.
Spirit Journal 2009 Rating:
Highly Recommended


Four Roses 2009 Limited Edition Single Barrel Kentucky Straight Bourbon Whiskey (USA; Four Roses Distillery, Lawrenceburg, KY); 113.8-116.9% range abv, $100.
Lovely light amber/orange color; flawless purity. Nose at opening is biscuity, woody (sawdust) and aggressively spirity; seven more minutes in the glass stimulate deeper aromas, including wood resin, unbuttered popcorn, and caramel corn. Entry is warming, intensely corny, and yet sharp as a razor's edge - not flabby or fat in the least as the acid level seems high; midpalate is more maple- and caramel-like than grainy or woody. Concludes warm as embers, composed as only topnotch straight bourbon can be when made with care, and powerful. This whiskey ripples with strength and depth. I recommend watering down two parts bourbon, one part water.
Spirit Journal 2009 Rating:
Highly Recommended


High West Whiskey 16 Year Old Rocky Mountain Rye Straight Rye Whiskey Batch No. 2/Bottle No. 939 (USA; High West Distillery, Park City, UT); 46% abv, $80.
Beautifully copper-like in color; unblemished purity. Smells alluringly of English toffee and baked bread in the opening whiffs; time in the glass affords the bouquet the chance to expand into areas of dried fruit (prunes, black raisins) and mince meat. Entry is deep and bittersweet, with delightful traces of candied nuts and baking spice; midpalate is long, honeyed/sherried, caramel-like, buttery, and intensely woody/oaky/bacon-like. Ends up tasting of charred meats, bacon, sausages, and BBQ rub. Dynamic, bittersweet, sap-like, and deep in character.
Spirit Journal 2009 Rating:
Highly Recommended


High West Whiskey 21 Year Old Rocky Mountain Rye Whiskey Batch No. 3/Bottle No. 997 (USA; High West Distillery, Park City, UT); 46% abv, $130.
Not a straight rye whiskey because it was matured in used barrels. Bronze/autumnal gold color; some large chunks of black sediment seen. Is biscuity in the initial inhalations, with plenty of bakery aromas, like dough, spices, yeast, lemon; seems to go a little flat and flabby after further air contact, losing much of the charm found in the first nosings. Entry is big in character and dry, then the taste profile turns sweet at midpalate, almost going corn-like rather than rye-like, which brings questions to my mind. It finishes quite well in a mildly woody/resiny manner but also in a pleasing grainy way. Inconsistent, but good enough to recommend.
Spirit Journal 2009 Rating:
Recommended


Old Fitzgerald Prime Bourbon Kentucky Straight Bourbon Whiskey (USA; Old Fitzgerald Distillery, Louisville, KY); 43% abv, $13.
Attractive deep amber/bronze color; excellent purity. Aroma is a touch mute in the first go-rounds after the pour, except for a paraffin scent; following aeration, a corn syrup/sweet corn fragrance emerges, but the nose overall is still rather undefined and vague. Entry tastes are harmonious and resiny; midpalate features oily/buttery flavors that are keenly woody, but there's an accompanying corny sweetness that works well. Finishes cereal sweet and oily.
Spirit Journal 2009 Rating:
Recommended


Old Fitzgerald Bottled-in-Bond Kentucky Straight Bourbon Whiskey (USA; Old Fitzgerald Distillery, Louisville, KY); 50% abv, $13.
Burnished orange/copper color; flawless clarity. High-flying spirity aromas come barreling out of the glass in waves, but there's also a nice marshmallow aspect that rounds off the edginess of the abv; after another six minutes in the glass the spirit dominates the aroma, yet there are alluring toasty/roasted nut scents that complement the spiritiness. Entry is surprisingly composed and integrated into the taste profile; at midpalate, the spirit aspect gradually grows in potency and warmth while the sweet corn/buttered popcorn flavors advance as well. Concludes on a warming note and the taste turns bittersweet and sap-like.
Spirit Journal 2009 Rating:
Highly Recommended


Old Forester 2008 Birthday Bourbon Kentucky Straight Bourbon Whiskey (USA; Brown-Forman Distilling Co., Louisville, KY); 47% abv, $40.
Glorious bronze color; impeccably clean. Nose is delicate yet firm in the first sniffs as soft aromas of toasted grain, roasted nuts, and tree sap converge for a lovely, even elegant opening aroma; seven more minutes of air contact bring out distant scents of brown butter and vanilla bean; wow. Entry is moderately oily, nutty/nougat-like, and even figgy; midpalate highlights flavors of toasted grains, honey, vanilla extract, charcoal, and brown sugar. Finishes long, silky, and semisweet. One of the best from this fabulous series.
Spirit Journal 2009 Rating:
Highest Recommendation


Parker's Heritage Collection Golden Anniversary Kentucky Straight Bourbon Whiskey (USA; Old Heaven Hill Springs Distillery, Bardstown, KY); 50% abv, $150.
Bottled to commemorate the golden anniversary of master distiller Parker Beam, a genuine distilling genius and one of the nicest men I know. Glorious topaz/burnished orange hue; impeccable purity. Rich, deep scents of caramel corn and brown butter are featured in the initial inhalations; another seven minutes of air contact add subtle aromas of prickly pear, old leather, nougat, and corn chips. Entry is ideally acidic and razor-sharp, but then the taste profile evolves quickly at midpalate into a focused experience that highlights popcorn, unsweetened breakfast cereal, almonds, and sweetish, charred oak. A lovely vanilla bean/honey taste wraps up the experience in the finish. A fitting tribute edition.
Spirit Journal 2009 Rating:
Highest Recommendation


Sazaerac Straight Rye Whiskey (USA; Buffalo Trace Distillery, Frankfort, KY); 45% abv, $25.
Bright copper color; unblemished purity. Opening nose is a bit too muted for its own good; aeration doesn't, to my disappointment, assist in stimulating much in the way of aromatics so I proceed directly to tasting. Entry is round, supple, and corny sweet; midpalate offers pleasant tastes of dried cherry and heavily toasted marshmallow. Ends up burnt, charcoal-like, toasted, and nicely sweet in a barbequed manner.
Spirit Journal 2009 Rating:
Recommended

© F. Paul Pacult
All rights reserved.

 
Ratings Key


Disappointing


Average


Above Average


Superb


Classic

Learn More About
Our Ratings
  

 

Subscribe to Spirit Journal  |  Primary Liquids Seminars
Tasting 101  |  Beer Style Guide  |  About Spirit Journal  |  About Our Ratings
F. Paul Pacult  |  Spirit Links  |  Paul's Upcoming Tastings

We welcome your comments and opinions:
email us